Skip to content

Black Friday all November: up to $1,000 off · Free insured shipping · Pay over time with Shop Pay

Black Friday Edit
Shop
Men's
Women's
Bridal
Custom Jewelry
About

X (Twitter)
Facebook
Pinterest
Instagram
YouTube

GEMTASTICJEWELRY Gemtastic Jewelry

Black Friday Edit
Shop
Men's
Women's
Bridal
Custom Jewelry
About

Search

Log in

Item added to your cart

View cart

Gemtastic Jewelry · The Collection

Collection: Gifts Under $1000

The Within Reach Collection

Real gold, real stones, real budget

4399 pieces

Sort by

Sort by:

4399 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

4399 products

Sort by:

Remove all

4399 products

Sterling Silver Pierced Cross Ring

Sterling Silver Pierced Cross Ring

Regular price $180

Regular price Sale price $180
14K White Gold Cultured White Freshwater Pearl 5-Station 7" Bracelet

14K White Gold Cultured White Freshwater Pearl 5-Station 7" Bracelet

Regular price $325

Regular price Sale price $325
Sterling Silver Elongated Cross Pendant

Sterling Silver Elongated Cross Pendant

Regular price $155

Regular price Sale price $155
Sterling Silver Cultured White Freshwater Pearl 5-Station 7.5" Bracelet

Sterling Silver Cultured White Freshwater Pearl 5-Station 7.5" Bracelet

Regular price $145

Regular price Sale price $145
14K Yellow Gold Heart Earrings

14K Yellow Gold Heart Earrings

Regular price $280

Regular price Sale price $280
Sterling Silver 10.8x8.8 mm Rectangle Cross Signet Ring

Sterling Silver 10.8x8.8 mm Rectangle Cross Signet Ring

Regular price $210

Regular price Sale price $210
Sterling Silver 26x16.5 mm Cross Ash Holder 18" Necklace

Sterling Silver 26x16.5 mm Cross Ash Holder 18" Necklace

Regular price $225

Regular price Sale price $225
Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross Pendant, 22.5 x 11 mm

Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross Pendant, 22.5 x 11 mm

Regular price $510

Regular price Sale price $510
22x11.5 mm Sideways Cross 16-18" Necklace

22x11.5 mm Sideways Cross 16-18" Necklace

Regular price $490

Regular price Sale price $490
Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross 16-18" Necklace

Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross 16-18" Necklace

Regular price From $295

Regular price Sale price From $295
14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl & .07 CTW Natural Diamond Cross 16-18" Necklace

14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl & .07 CTW Natural Diamond Cross 16-18" Necklace

Regular price $940

Regular price Sale price $940
14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl Sideways Cross 16-18" Necklace

14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl Sideways Cross 16-18" Necklace

Regular price $735

Regular price Sale price $735
14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl Youth Cross Pendant

14K Yellow Gold Cultured White Seed Pearl Youth Cross Pendant

Regular price $575

Regular price Sale price $575
14K Yellow Gold .06 CTW Natural Diamond Earrings

14K Yellow Gold .06 CTW Natural Diamond Earrings

Regular price $330

Regular price Sale price $330
Cultured White Seed Pearl Youth Cross 16" Necklace

Cultured White Seed Pearl Youth Cross 16" Necklace

Regular price $600

Regular price Sale price $600
Petite Cross Slide Pendant

Petite Cross Slide Pendant

Regular price $335

Regular price Sale price $335
Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross Pendant, 20.8 x 14.1 mm

Cultured White Freshwater Pearl Cross Pendant, 20.8 x 14.1 mm

Regular price $945

Regular price Sale price $945
25x24 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

25x24 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

Regular price $1,035

Regular price Sale price $1,035
18x18 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

18x18 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

Regular price $570

Regular price Sale price $570
14K Yellow Gold .01 CTW Natural Diamond Youth Heart Earrings

14K Yellow Gold .01 CTW Natural Diamond Youth Heart Earrings

Regular price $465

Regular price Sale price $465
Youth Puffed Heart Earrings

Youth Puffed Heart Earrings

Regular price $295

Regular price Sale price $295
Cultured Pearl & .03 CTW Natural Diamond Contour Band

Cultured Pearl & .03 CTW Natural Diamond Contour Band

Regular price From $885

Regular price Sale price From $885
Sterling Silver 30x29 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

Sterling Silver 30x29 mm Four-Way Cross Medal

Regular price $205

Regular price Sale price $205
Cultured White Seed Pearl & .03 CTW Natural Diamond Contour Band

Cultured White Seed Pearl & .03 CTW Natural Diamond Contour Band

Regular price From $795

Regular price Sale price From $795
Nugget Cross Pendant

Nugget Cross Pendant

Regular price $165

Regular price Sale price $165
14K Yellow Gold .015 CTW Natural Diamond Cross Pendant

14K Yellow Gold .015 CTW Natural Diamond Cross Pendant

Regular price $270

Regular price Sale price $270
14K White Gold 1/6 CT Natural Diamond Slide Pendant

14K White Gold 1/6 CT Natural Diamond Slide Pendant

Regular price $515

Regular price Sale price $515
.07 CTW Natural Diamond Sideways Cross Ring

.07 CTW Natural Diamond Sideways Cross Ring

Regular price $770

Regular price Sale price $770
14K Yellow Gold 1/4 CT Natural Diamond Slide Pendant

14K Yellow Gold 1/4 CT Natural Diamond Slide Pendant

Regular price $595

Regular price Sale price $595
Sterling Silver .08 CTW Natural Diamond Sideways Cross Ring

Sterling Silver .08 CTW Natural Diamond Sideways Cross Ring

Regular price $375

Regular price Sale price $375
.04 CTW Bar Earring Top — Natural or Lab-Grown Diamond

.04 CTW Bar Earring Top — Natural or Lab-Grown Diamond

Regular price From $205

Regular price Sale price From $205
1/6 Natural Diamond Bar Earring Top

1/6 Natural Diamond Bar Earring Top

Regular price $610

Regular price Sale price $610
Sideways Cross Ring

Sideways Cross Ring

Regular price $510

Regular price Sale price $510
Sterling Silver Side Cross Ring

Sterling Silver Side Cross Ring

Regular price $170

Regular price Sale price $170
14K Yellow Gold Hinged Hoop Earring

14K Yellow Gold Hinged Hoop Earring

Regular price $585

Regular price Sale price $585
14K White Gold Beaded Sideways Cross Ring

14K White Gold Beaded Sideways Cross Ring

Regular price $455

Regular price Sale price $455

1
…
25
26
27
28
29
…
123

GEMTASTICJEWELRY

Heirlooms begin here.

A fine jewelry house led by a master jeweler.

(414) 324-0498
GemtasticJewelry@gmail.com
Mon–Fri 10–5 · Sat 11–4 (Central)

Collections

All Jewelry
Rings
Necklaces & Pendants
Earrings
Bracelets
Charms
Wedding & Engagement
In Memory Of
Gifts
Birthstone

Client care

Ring & Bracelet Size Guide
Shipping & Made-to-Order
How We Inspect
Returns & Exchanges
Jewelry & Diamond Care
FAQ

The house

About Us
Contact Us
Custom Jewelry
Layaway
Contact Information

© 2026 Gemtastic Jewelry LLC

Payment Methods
Billing Terms and Conditions
Privacy Policy
Refund Policy
Shipping Policy
Terms of Service

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.